罗伯特李欧美历届十大军事将领在欧美历届十大军事将领中排名第10名。

·······································································

我们精选了部分网友观点：

···································································

李是一个不错的防御一般,但可怜的进攻。他进攻活动基本上摧毁了军队的北弗吉尼亚出血death.How多的敌人军队他摧毁了吗?他著名的胜利是非常被高估了。军队钱瑟勒斯维尔战役后不久,他在葛底斯堡击败了阻止他重losses.His伟大的力量击败了他面临的联盟军队,但在击败敌人的指挥官,导致他们撤退后刺痛的,但非决定性的打击。所有的联盟军队他再次击败能够战斗,很快李defeats.When后面临着他不能恐吓格兰特将军他被迫战斗技巧但最终失去运动。在运动造成的失败与他的早些时候,所不同的是,对方一般没有吓倒。一旦发生他军队被注定,因为他从来没有能够施加决定性的失败答摧毁…更多

Lee was a decent defensive general, but poor when on offense. His offensive campaigns basically destroyed the Army of Northern Virginia by bleeding it to death.How many enemy armies did he destroy? His famous victories are very overrated. Shortly after Chancellorsville the army he defeated was stopping him at Gettysburg with heavy losses.His great strength was not defeating the Union armies he faced, but in defeating the enemy commander, causing them to retreat after taking a stinging but, non-decisive blow. All the Union armies he defeated were capable of fighting again, very soon after their defeats.When Lee faced a general he could not intimidate (Grant) he was forced to fight a skillful but ultimately losing campaign. In that campaign he inflicted defeats comparable to his earlier ones, the difference was that the opposing general was not intimidated. Once that happened his army was doomed, since he was never able to inflict a decisive defeat tat destroyed ... more

···································································

李是神相比,格兰特。严重超过3比1他应该在前五名,但不是第一。我相信他更值得尊重的原因是因为他的选择容易赢得与工会但争取南部和伸出了四年!当他失去了他保持着honorful骄傲。

Lee was a God compared to Grant. Seriously he was outnumbered 3 to 1 he deserves to be in top 5, but not first. The reason I believe he deserves more respect is because he had the choice for the easy win with the union but fought for the south and held out for 4 years! And when he lost he maintained an honorful pride.

···································································

经常忘记李一个事实是,他不是南方部队的指挥官在内战。他吩咐一个军队,和这一个军队的总国防CSA进行。他不允许任何命令在他的国家所使用的全面战争策略,和没有控制资源,部队动向、和物流,为赢得战争。这一事实他的国家资源管理不善,没有一个有凝聚力的国防合作,并提供长期战争,没有生产资料说明了李和有效的策略是多么重要。而欧盟能够关注他们的整个战争策略在音乐会对韩国,李成为南方后,他赢得了胜利战胜更大、更好的装备,训练有素,和更好的联邦军队。没有其他指挥官这个列表必须与这些障碍,并没有其他的指挥官就会看到李的成功如果他们。很容易说,自从邦联丢失,…更多

One fact that is often forgotten about Lee is that he was not the commander of the confederate forces in the Civil War. He commanded one army, and with that single army conducted the total defense of the CSA. He was not allowed any command over the total war strategy used by his country, and had no control over resources, troop movements, and logistics that go into winning a war. The fact that his country mismanaged resources, did not collaborate in a cohesive defense, and offered not means of production for a prolonged war, illustrates how important and effective Lee's tactics really were. While the union were able to focus their whole war strategy in concert against the south, Lee became the south as he won victory after victory against larger, better equipped, better trained, and better fed troops. No other commander on this list had to fight with such handicaps, and no other commander would have seen Lee's success if they had to. It's easy to say that since the confederacy lost, ... more

···································································

李被高估了,当然不是在同一个类中最大的世界历史。葛底斯堡是获胜,并可能在战争的幽灵和平民主党1864年选举的焦点。但由于错误由李和他的下属饰和山,他的失误,他是负责他们的胜利,他击败了乔治·米德和失去了战争和战争果断——唯一的战争中他是一个主要的player.Moreover,李的水平和成功的频率明显下降,立即“石墙”杰克逊的死亡。而显然有其他因素在起作用,我认为这是合理的给杰克逊健康的信贷份额李的早期成功,或者错李教练对他的能力较小的执行官员充分保持成功。

Lee is overrated, and certainly isn't in the same class as the greatest of world history. Gettysburg was winnable, and likely the war with it due to the spectre of the peace democrats looming over the 1864 election. But due to mistakes by Lee and by his subordinates like Ewell and Hill, whose blunders he is as much responsible for as their triumphs, he was outmaneuvered by George Meade and lost both the battle and war decisively- the only war in which he was ever a major player.Moreover, Lee's level and frequency of success declined markedly and immediately upon the death of Stonewall Jackson. While there were obviously other factors in play, I believe it's reasonable to give Jackson a healthy share of the credit for Lee's early success, or alternatively to fault Lee for his inability to coach up lesser officers to execute adequately to maintain that success.

···································································

李人手不足和没有资源来补充需要的武器和弹药,以及士兵。然而,他的策略和勇气帮助韩国赢得神奇victories.Gettysburg应该是令人震惊的胜利南然而,尤厄尔在战争中受伤前,失去了他的神经,退回到镇上他的部队之后,朝鲜highground。他呆在外面,事情会变得强大interesting.Lee绝对是一位伟大的将军。甚至争取一个原因,他不相信。他荣誉回家,和家人。

Lee was undermanned and without resources to replenish needed arms and ammunition, as well as soldiers, in the field. However, his strategy and courage helped the south win amazing victories.Gettysburg should have been an astounding win for the south however, Ewell who had been injured earlier in the war, lost his nerve and retreated back into the town after his troops had run the North off the highground. Had he stayed put, things would have becoming mighty interesting.Lee is definitely one of the great generals of all time. Even fighting for a cause that he didn't believe in. He did honor home, and family.

I defy anyone to point out a military leader who had been provided more underwhelming materials and supplies and was as successful as Lee. I am a Californian, born to a New York couple. So this isn't shrouded in southern pride. He was simply better. But not able to overcome the shortcomings and short supply of his forces. And, 'yes,' Stonewall Jackson was an incredibly adept general and was a serious loss to Lee. Perhaps even a better general than Lee (debatable). But Lee has to go down as one of the all time greatest generals in history.

···································································

战争历史的教授,毕业于西点军校我不相信有人会写点东西,所以逃避的事实与我交谈过的许多学生和专业人士在这个领域以及伟大leaders.我父亲很新的艾森豪威尔都同意罗伯特E李策略是优秀的声音大部分唯一能说的是他不是很好但是我能找到的唯一原因,有人会说这样的事情可能是,因为问题的时候必须看事实和事实本身,而不考虑人的感受但是无情这听起来它必须记住心脏无关我们感知和解释,有时云是观点的事实。中尉Col.R。罗宾逊jr。

As a professor of War history and a graduate of West Point I can't believe someone would write something so evasive of facts I have spoken with many students and professionals in this field as well as great leaders. my father new Eisenhower very well all agreed Robert E Lee strategy was excellent sound for the most part the only thing that can be said is he was not good with men. the only reason I can find that one would say such things is perhaps because of the issues of the time one must look at facts and facts alone and not consider one's feelings however heartless this may sound it must be kept in mind that heart has nothing to do with it is our perception and interpretation that sometimes clouds are views from the facts. Lt. Col.R. Robinson jr.

···································································

他一手背后所有的联盟成功和失败的战争是一个军队的指挥官保护一个分崩离析的国家没有供应或制造,受到了一个几乎完全防御战争时,他命令所有入侵北部的土壤被北维吉尼亚州的军队只有少数没有他尽管在灰色的石墙杰克逊和其他伟大的男孩nathen福勒斯特贝德福德邦联可能已经持续了5个月更别说5年

He was single handedly behind all of the confederacys success and failure for most of the war being the commander of one army protecting a falling apart country with no supplies or manufacturing that was subjected to a nearly completely defensive war when he commanded all invasions of northern soil being only a few by the army of north Virginia without him despite the other great boys in gray like stonewall Jackson and nathen Forrest Bedford the confederacy may have lasted 5 months let alone 5 years

···································································

+ u2018We知道上帝是谁…但这是李将军。+ u2018他举行了军队在一起了四年之久,应该迅速湮灭。美国三个和一年半才击败日本和德国,但李的光着脚的士兵举行半年了。李完成不仅通过他的天才,也因为他的神一般的质量。他的人对他有信心的是值得胜利的一半。

"We know who God is... but here is General Lee." He held an army together for four long years that should have been annihilated quickly. It took America three and one half years to defeat the Japanese and Germans but Lee's barefooted soldiers held on for half a year longer. Lee accomplished much not only through his genius but also because of his god-like gualities. His men had confidence in him which was worth half the victory.

···································································

极其聪明,经验丰富,忠于职守,忠诚,有纪律的,有礼貌的人。对我有偏见,我是维吉尼亚州的生活在列克星敦附近,他埋葬,但他的军事力量是如此之大,工会拼命试图让他整个联盟的将军军事陆军和海军!他拒绝当我和维吉尼亚州脱离联邦的家中有一个极端的对这个人的尊重。

An extremely brilliant, skilled, dedicated, loyal, disciplined and polite man. Call me biased as I am a Virginian that lives near Lexington where he is buried but his military prowess was so great that the Union desperately tried to make him the General of the entire UNION MILITARY ARMY AND NAVY! He declined when his home state of Virginia seceded and I have an extreme respect for this man.