埃里希·冯·曼斯坦(Erich von Manstein )——欧美最佳二战德国陆军元帅

埃里希冯曼斯坦(Erich von Manstein )——欧美最佳二战德国陆军元帅在《欧美最佳二战德国陆军元帅》中排名第1名。我们精选了部分网友观点： ...

埃里希冯曼斯坦欧美最佳二战德国陆军元帅在欧美最佳二战德国陆军元帅中排名第1名。

·······································································

我们精选了部分网友观点：

···································································

显然比隆美尔强.如果不是希特勒，曼斯坦本可以拯救被包围的第六军.斯大林格勒灾难后，他能够稳定南部前线，发起反攻，夺回查尔科夫.“乌特内曼-齐塔德尔”（库尔斯克战役）也是他的主意，但希特勒命令他们等到夏天1943年，红军有足够的时间来巩固他们的防线.对他作为最好的德国费尔德马尔沙尔的地位来说，同样重要的是，冯·曼斯坦从来没有下令处决平民、犹太人或任何其他民族.他不是种族主义者，也不是纳粹党成员

Clearly better than Rommel. If it wasn't for Hitler, Manstein would have save the encircled 6th Army. After the Stalingrad disaster he was able to stabilize the front in the south and launched a counter offensive recapturing charkov. The "Unternehmen Zitadelle" (battle of Kursk) was also his idea, but Hitler ordered them to wait until Summer 1943. So the Red army had enough time to fortify their defense lines. Also important for his status as the best german Feldmarschall is the fact, that von Manstein never gave a order to execute civilians, jews or any other ethnic group. He was no racist or member of the Nazi party.

···································································

费尔德马尔夏尔·冯·曼斯坦显然是德国军队中最好的前线军官。尽管德国确实派出了世界上最训练有素的军队。军官、士官和舒茨都受过如此高程度的交叉训练，以至于当他们的领导人在战场上倒下时，各个击破了先机。希特勒减少了装甲师和步兵师的规模，增加了更多的师，但减少了旅和团。因此，先前的有效兵力丧失了。冯·曼斯坦和他的同僚们在这场变革中没有成功。因此，随着战争的推进，为了拯救士兵，军官们不得不即兴发挥。如果允许像1939年和1940年将军们那样继续下去，德国人就会压垮俄国人。如果德国人制造出“乌拉尔”六引擎重型轰炸机，那么他们就可以在“乌拉尔”山后面对俄罗斯工厂进行大规模轰炸，更有效地轰炸英国，再加上轰炸美国东海岸。多亏了希特勒，它被取消了，战争也失败了

Feldmarschall Von Manstein was clearly the best line officer in the German Army. Although Germany did field the best trained army the World has ever seen. Officers, NCO's and Schutze were cross trained to such a high degree, that when their leaders fell in battle, each could step in an lead. Hitler reduced the size of Panzer and Infantry Divisions by adding more Divisions but with less brigades and regiments. Therefore, the prior effective force was lost. Von Manstein and his peers fought this change without success. So as the war moved forward, officers had to improvise in order to save their troopers. Allowed to continue as the Generals did in 1939 1940, the Germans would have crushed the Russians. Had the Germans produced the "Ural" six engine heavy bomber, then they could have massed bombed the Russian factories behind the "Ural" mountains, bomb Britain more effectively plus bombing the U.S. east Coast. Thanks to Hitler, it was cancelled and the war lost.

···································································

马歇尔·曼施泰因是一位杰出的战术家，他明白战争必须如何进行。令人遗憾的是，他没有被允许做他计划的事情，这导致了德国军队的逆转。正如其他人之前所说，如果希特勒允许他的陆军元帅/将军们指挥他们的战斗，我们所看到的历史就是这样今天和今天不同，曼斯坦的反攻非常出色，今天他的许多作战计划都是全世界军事学院的案例研究

Field Marshall Manstein was a brillant tactician who understood how the warfare had to be conducted. It is indeed sad that he was not allowed to do what he had planned and this led to the reversal of the German army. As said earlier by others if Hitler had allowed his Field Marshalls / Generals to conduct their battles, the history what we see today and what would have been would be different. Manstein counter offensives were brillant and today many of his battle plans are case studies in the military academy worl wide.

···································································

现代坦克战争大师，曼斯坦计划的创造者，克里米亚（世界上最坚固的堡垒）的胜利者，大部分时间都没有盔甲的支持，冲向列宁格勒，在那里他表现出色，结果被冲向斯大林格勒去救第六军，这是他几乎成功的工作。溃败后，他在“反手一击”中展现了自己的天才，赢得了哈尔科夫并稳定了东部战线。即使在库尔斯克战役中，他指挥的南方钳子也表现出色，几乎完成了包围，但苏联在普罗霍罗夫卡的恢复力。我一直以来最喜欢的德国野战马歇尔，其次是古德里亚模型n隆美尔

Master of modern Tank warfare, creator of the Manstein Plan, winner of Crimea (world's strongest fortress) that too without support of armour for most of the time, rushed to Leningrad where he performed superbly, only to be rushed towards Stalingrad to rescue 6th Army, a job he almost succeeded in. After the rout, he showed his genius in the'backhand blow' to win Kharkov n stabilise the Eastern front. Even in battle of Kursk, the southern pincer which was under his command performed commendably and almost completed the encirclement but for the Soviet resilience at Prokhorovka. My all time favourite German Field Marshall, followed by Guderian Model n Rommel.

···································································

作为一个伟大的战略家，如果希特勒让曼斯泰因控制战争，我们也许会在德国的统治之下，因为他可以在1942年12月突破斯大林格勒前线，从而阻止俄国对第六军的包围，他也不象其他纳粹最高统帅部那样追随希特勒

A great strategist, If Hitler had let Manstein control the war, we probably would maybe be under German rule know as he would of been able to break through the Stalingrad front in December 1942 thus stopping the Russian encirclement of 6th army in that city. He was also known not to follow Hitler as much as the other Nazi high command did

···································································

显然，在战争策略上，他占了上风，希特勒一如既往地因为害怕报复或兵变而关闭他最优秀的将领。曼斯坦尽管不断地抗议希特勒的决定，但他仍然忠于普鲁士的军事原则。毫无疑问，他是他那个时代最好的军事战略家！

Clearly he had the upper hand when it comes to warfare strategies, Hitler as always kept on shutting down his finest generals in fear of reprisals or mutiny. Manstein despite his constant protests against Hitler's decisions, he remained faithful to his Prussian military principals. Undoubtedly he was the best military strategist of his time!

···································································

他在德国和希特勒将军的军事实力中，被称为“最优秀的德国和希特勒的战术”，这可能是因为他在德国和希特勒将军的军事技巧中都是最优秀的

Probably the best German General. He was called "the fireman" for putting fires Hitler had set, because of his ego. Each German General had his good points and strengths but among historian he rates among the highest, and his tactics are studied in American Military Academies for their sheer brilliance.

···································································

曼斯坦的《失败者》一书是必读之作，曼斯坦的战略意识和作战意识高度发达，为愤怒线下的军官提供了一个按照整体意图行动和冒险的框架，在这个意义上，曼斯坦出色地表达了老赫尔穆思·冯·莫尔特克的遗产

Manstein's book 'Lost Victories' is a must read. Manstein had a highly developed sense of strategy and operations and hence provided a framework for officers down rage line to make moves and take risks in accordance with the overall intent. In this sense Manstein was brilliantly expressed the legacy of Helmuth Von Moltke the Elder.

···································································

冯·曼斯坦在二战期间是德国国防军最优秀的指挥官。他在1940年的西方进攻计划中的辉煌计划，克里米亚的攻势，以及以收复哈尔科夫为高潮的南部俄军进攻，以及第六军的几乎解放，都是他能够掌控战场的例子，不像隆美尔在阿拉曼战役中两败俱伤

Von Manstein was quite simply the best commander in the Wehrmacht during WW2. His brilliant plan for the Western Offensive in 1940, the capture of the Crimea, his southern Russian offensive culminating in the recapture of Kharkov the near liberation of the 6th Army are all examples of his ability to achieve mastery of the battlefield, unlike Rommel who lost both Battles Of Alamein.

···································································

他是一个军事（战术）属。他的学派认为，军队的所有部门不仅要机动，而且要灵活、迅速。他果断果断，深受部下的爱戴，备受尊敬。然而希特勒从不信任他，这使他付出了战争的代价。多些评论吧，达尔；

He was a military (tactical ) genus. It was his school of thought that all branches of the military should be not only mobile but fluid, and swift. He was decisive and well loved by his men, highly respected. Hitler never trusted him however and it cost him the war. show more comments darr;